01Fictitious supplier and segregation of duties
The fictitious supplier remains the most common scheme: one person creates a supplier, approves spend and triggers payment to an account they control. It survives only where roles are not separated.
The defense is segregation of duties, enforced by software rather than by goodwill: creating a supplier, approving a requisition and executing a payment belong to three distinct roles. Every action is timestamped in an audit trail no one can rewrite, which alone is often deterrent enough.
02Overbilling and three-way matching
Collusive overbilling is quieter: a real supplier invoices above the agreed price or delivered volume, the difference shared with a complicit buyer. The supplier exists and delivers, which dulls vigilance.
Three-way matching confronts the invoice with the purchase order and the receipt. A gap blocks payment and raises an exception an authorized role must justify. Tracking the exception rate per buyer surfaces those who force overrides too often — the signal an auditor looks for.
03Double payment and bank-detail hijack
Double payment often starts as an error: the same invoice settled twice, once manually then in an EFT run, the overpayment never reclaimed. A duplicate check on invoice number, supplier and amount, before disbursement, eliminates it.
Bank-detail hijack is rising fast: a fraudster mimics a supplier and asks to change the account before a due date. The defense combines procedure and software: any bank-detail change triggers dual-control validation and an alert, and history stays traceable. EFT CPA-005 payments themselves pass under initiator-approver dual control.
04The evidence the auditor asks for
An external auditor does not judge your honesty, they test your controls: is segregation of duties enforced by the system, are exceptions justified, are supplier and account changes traced, is the log tamper-evident.
Procure-to-Pay software answers natively. Where a spreadsheet folder rests on memory, the system says who did what, when, on which document, in a few clicks. For a Québec SME, that is mission time saved and risk removed — while securing GST and QST credits, which rest on the same well-kept documents.